Thesis Doctoral
Permanent URI for this collectionhttps://hdl.handle.net/1959.11/26180
Browse
Browsing Thesis Doctoral by Department "Institute for Rural Futures"
- Results Per Page
- Sort Options
- Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralBest practice management of pasture weeds in Southern Australia(2008) ;Trotter, Mark Graeme; ; Scott, JamesWeeds are known to have a great financial impact on the Australian grazing industry. Integrated weed management is widely considered to be the solution to the pasture weed problem. Through surveying the indigenous knowledge of graziers this project sought to identify the best management practices for pasture weeds of southern Australia and the challenges that producers face in implementing them. In addition, this project also aimed to validate the producer perceptions which were relied upon for much of this study and identify the pasture weeds of most concern to graziers throughout southern Australia. The project consisted of five major research activities which were: key informant interviews; a postal survey sent to 7,000 graziers; an on-farm validation study; telephone interviews; and producer focus groups. Although preliminary in nature, the results of the validation study indicated that producers are able to report most weed densities to within 5% canopy cover. However, many producers were unable to identify the annual grass weed vulpia ('Vulpia' spp.). Respondents to the postal survey reported an estimated 328 plants as undesirable species, dominated by annual broadleaf weeds. The most commonly reported species included capeweed, Paterson's curse, saffron thistle, blackberry and barley grass. The best management practices were examined for the most commonly reported weeds in four functional groups.1886 1195 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralCan Reflexive Governance Deliver Integrated Water Resources Management Outcomes in Bangladesh?(2014) ;Islam, Md Nazrul; ; ;Lahiri-Dutt, KuntalaGill, RodericThe Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM) is a continuous process which has emerged as an international policy discourse to address the issue of sustainable water development and management. There is also criticism over the excessive emphasis on the usage of the terminology 'IWRM'. Despite criticism, it is argued by many that IWRM could be a way forward to tackle the crisis of water management. The objective of this thesis is to find a 'reflexive solution' to overcome the obstacles in implementing the Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM) principles in Bangladesh using a multi-disciplinary management approach. The findings of the study may be useful for Bangladesh as well other countries to progress implementation of IWRM principles. The practical implementation of IWRM espoused by the Global Water Partnership (GWP) and many others would be difficult in many countries including Bangladesh with the existing structure of the governance of the water resource management. IWRM concepts encompass social, political, economic, environmental and cultural aspects of water, land and the community. Implementation of the principles of IWRM in countries like Bangladesh needs a 'reflexive approach' and would face political and resource constraint challenges. It is widely perceived that integration of IWRM principles is possible through reflexive and adaptive water institutions with a multi-disciplinary approach. It is difficult to implement IWRM based on the foundation of 'less integrated' and certainly less 'reflexive' structure for water resources policy planning and management. The research question has been put forward as 'Can 'reflexive governance' help deliver IWRM outcomes in Bangladesh?'3398 556 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Thesis DoctoralPublication Conflict, Consensus and Planning: Negotiations in NSW Water and Vegetation Committees(2010) ;Prior, Julian Chisholm; Environmental disputation in Australia has increased over the last decade. This phenomenon is the result of the confluence of three interdependent forces of change. Firstly, federal and state governments have become increasingly interventionist in the definition and proscription of access and use rights to natural resources such as native vegetation, water, mineral resources and fisheries. Secondly, governments had been inclined to encourage, or at least allow, increasing levels of public participation in the development and implementation of natural resource policy. Thirdly, and perhaps in response to the first two influences, there has been an increase in the number and capacity of organised, articulate and politically astute stakeholder organisations representing their groups' interests in the political decision-making process and the media. ... This research sought to learn from the experiences of 11 case study water and vegetation committees. The aim of the research was to identify and analyse those factors that either enhanced or constrained the process of consensus decision making on these committees. A potential conceptual framework, cognitive frames theory, was identified from a review of the literature, and its relevance and utility assessed as a device for analysing complex, multiple-stakeholder negotiations, through its application to the case study committees. Cognitive frames are defined as the conceptual filters or road maps that help us organise our knowledge and interpret the meaning of new information, events and experiences. Cognitive frames are considered important in negotiations because in the minds of the participants they define the 'problem' being addressed within the negotiation; they may determine the strategies adopted by negotiators; and they may determine the outcomes being sought by them.2562 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Thesis DoctoralPublication Creating inspiration: how the visual and performing arts shape environmental behaviour(University of New England, 2008-04-12) ;Curtis, David John; ; Reid, JohnAustralia faces many environmental problems of considerable scale and complexity. These include high greenhouse gas emissions, pressures on coral reefs, continuing net loss of tree cover and native vegetation, soil erosion, soil salinity, declining water quality and quantity, continuing threats to biodiversity, increasing pressures from urban areas due to population increases and increased per capita consumption, and climate change. Many factors contribute to the environmental behaviour of individuals, and through their combined actions, to society's. Australia faces many environmental problems of considerable scale and complexity. These include high greenhouse gas emissions, pressures on coral reefs, continuing net loss of tree cover and native vegetation, soil erosion, soil salinity, declining water quality and quantity, continuing threats to biodiversity, increasing pressures from urban areas due to population increases and increased per capita consumption, and climate change. Many factors contribute to the environmental behaviour of individuals, and through their combined actions, to society's.
This study investigated the effects that visual and performing arts can have on the environmental behaviour of individuals, communities and broader society, with a view to providing recommendations on how to more effectively harness the arts in order to promote ecological sustainability. The research aims were to: This study investigated the effects that visual and performing arts can have on the environmental behaviour of individuals, communities and broader society, with a view to providing recommendations on how to more effectively harness the arts in order to promote ecological sustainability. The research aims were to:
• investigate how the visual and performing arts are both deliberately and unconsciously used in shaping perceptions towards the environment in Australia and internationally;
• describe how people and organisations working towards environmental repair and conservation have used arts-based modes of communication;
• integrate theory of how environmental behaviour is determined and the impact that the arts have on that process;
• use a series of events that incorporate the arts and environmental repair, to evaluate the role of the arts in changing people's behaviour towards the environment;
• determine if art events can aid participation by a broad cross section of the community, can strengthen a community's abilities to promote inclusion, and can be powerful vehicles for community mobilisation, empowerment, and information transfer;
• determine what role the arts might have in shaping ecological sustainability at a societal level; and
• develop policy recommendations for extension and environmental education programs.
The selection of research methods was guided by methodological pragmatism, drawing from a range of social science paradigms according to circumstance. A quasi-grounded theory approach was used in some stages of the project. This interlaced data collection and analysis so that emerging concepts and theoretical constructs were grounded in the life experience of the research participants. In other stages, social constructivist methods such as focus groups and in-depth semi-structured interviews were employed. Through data collection prior to and after arts events, the project approach used logical positivist methods to provide evidence of the impact of arts events and the causes underlying these impacts. The purposeful methodological diversity added cross-disciplinary force to the thesis, and enabled triangulation between the different types of data, to afford greater confidence in the conclusions.
I found that the work of individual artists can influence the behaviour of citizens through 'internally derived I found that the work of individual artists can influence the behaviour of citizens through 'internally derived' interventions, which impinge on a person's values, beliefs, knowledge, attitudes, self-identity and habits, and through these, on social norms. However, desire by individuals to adopt pro-environmental behaviour can be hampered by situational or infrastructure constraints. I also found that the arts have a role in reducing some of these constraints, through 'externalist interventions' where the arts are embedded into ecologically sustainable development. This might be where community and public art are incorporated into urban planning as a means of making active transport modes more attractive, or where the arts provide alternative forms of consumption which are lower in embodied energy and higher in embodied labour.The degree to which a person responds to the arts will depend on personal characteristics (e.g. gender, class, etc.), situation, institutional factors, as well as the type of art. The accumulated result of individual behaviours leads to macro-level impacts on the environment. A knowledge of these impacts in turn influences individual artists, and affects their practice.
I found that the arts could foster pro-environmental behaviour through one of three 'pathways'. The first pathway is where the visual and performing arts are used to synthesise complex ideas and to communicate them to non-specialist audiences in an engaging form. This makes the arts valuable in enhancing the teaching of scientific or environmental material and raising awareness about environmental issues in a wide range of contexts. The arts have been used because of these qualities by practitioners, both in Australia and overseas. The arts are also a medium for articulating a dissenting or critical voice which prompts people to look at issues in new ways. Some artists are at the forefront in challenging dominant social paradigms and are active participants in attempts to improve the environmental behaviour of individuals and of society. I found that the arts could foster pro-environmental behaviour through one of three 'pathways'. The first pathway is where the visual and performing arts are used to synthesise complex ideas and to communicate them to non-specialist audiences in an engaging form. This makes the arts valuable in enhancing the teaching of scientific or environmental material and raising awareness about environmental issues in a wide range of contexts. The arts have been used because of these qualities by practitioners, both in Australia and overseas. The arts are also a medium for articulating a dissenting or critical voice which prompts people to look at issues in new ways. Some artists are at the forefront in challenging dominant social paradigms and are active participants in attempts to improve the environmental behaviour of individuals and of society.
A second pathway is where the arts and particular artists connect their audience to the natural environment through thoughtful or evocative representations of the environment or by being in the natural environment itself. Similarly, the celebratory aspects of the performing arts make them useful in affirming ecological restoration and environmental repair activities in a non-didactic way. Modem life in Western society has disconnected most people from the natural environment, and the arts provide a way of re-establishing this link. The art described under this pathway exemplifies the important role of artists in aiding understanding of the Australian natural environment and its native flora and fauna, complementing the role of ecologists. Through experiencing artistic explorations a community can develop empathy toward the natural environment, and this is vital in developing a caring relationship for it. A second pathway is where the arts and particular artists connect their audience to the natural environment through thoughtful or evocative representations of the environment or by being in the natural environment itself. Similarly, the celebratory aspects of the performing arts make them useful in affirming ecological restoration and environmental repair activities in a non-didactic way. Modem life in Western society has disconnected most people from the natural environment, and the arts provide a way of re-establishing this link. The art described under this pathway exemplifies the important role of artists in aiding understanding of the Australian natural environment and its native flora and fauna, complementing the role of ecologists. Through experiencing artistic explorations a community can develop empathy toward the natural environment, and this is vital in developing a caring relationship for it.
Several case studies were studied that had elements of both the first and second pathways. The case studies demonstrated that celebrations and festivals can be successfully linked with conservation of the environment, and can allow conservation and care of the environment to penetrate many social networks. An event involving music, theatre, dance and spectacle can have many effects on participants and audiences. Such events can encourage people to reflect on their and others' relationship with the environment, and can affect people emotionally and engender positive feelings for the environment. They also have a strong capacity for engendering appreciation and pride in community and can act to strengthen those bonds. They can involve a large number of people, and therefore expand the audience or awareness-rasing about the environment I hey alow partcpants to develop the for awareness-raising about the environment. They allow participants to develop their ideas, to learn about issues and to express their feelings for those issues. They also have an effect in affirming beliefs, reminding, and reinforcing existing knowledge and values, and in prompting changes in people who have not been exposed to those ideas. The case studies showed that large art events with an environmental theme can influence both those whose environmental behaviour is poorly developed as well as those whose behaviour is already good. The process of engagement is particularly important, especially if the message of the work can be carried through in the ways the work is realised. The actual process of being involved is important in learning and consolidating one's ideas and knowledge. The impact of the message is enhanced through repetition and added exposure, and the effects can endure long after the event 1s over.
The third pathway is where the arts are embedded in ecologically sustainable development, through the combined effects of community development, economic development, and changes in the patterns of consumption. Examples from urban contexts were examined, where public and community art were integrated into urban planning which was designed around improved active transport modes. Australia's environmental impact is driven by consumption that is high in embodied energy, water and resources. Because the arts industry is low in embodied energy and resources and high in embodied labour, it will be an important segment of the economy in a 'post-consumer' society that has lower levels of environmental impact. The arts can also be integrated with ecologically sustainable development in rural areas. Examples include the links between landscape architecture and landscape aesthetics and the farm planning and landcare movements, as well as the linking of ecological art with ecological restoration. The community and participatory arts have an important role in catalysing ecological sustainability, particularly through their ability to foster altruism. Community arts events have a strong community-building role and can be linked with celebrations of ecologically sustainable behaviours and aspirations.
452 5 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralExtending Complex Agricultural Research in Australia: The case of integrated parasite management in sheep(2009) ;Thompson, Lyndal-Joy; ; In many agricultural industries around the world, the use of chemicals for pest or parasite control has resulted in the resistance of many of these organisms to chemicals. This has rendered many agricultural chemicals less effective or completely ineffective, leading to interest in more holistic management approaches such as integrated pest management (IPM). An IPM approach comprises biological, chemical, genetic and cultural components. Research into resistance of livestock parasites has increased over the past two decades, however very few IPM programs, in the Australian livestock industry at least, have been developed to successfully manage parasitic resistance to chemicals. Parasites cost the Australian sheep industry nearly AUD369 million per annum. Further, pressure is mounting from overseas markets, and the public, for 'clean and green' animal products with low levels of chemical residues. With resistance to chemicals only increasing, the industry has reached a critical phase regarding how it manages the chemical issue. The Integrated Parasite Management in sheep Project (IPM-s) was commissioned by Australian Wool Innovations Ltd to develop regional plans for integrated parasite management for the sheep industry. The project is multi-disciplinary, and comprises programs related to critical research in parasite ecology, and a socio-economic component to identify key benchmark indicators of parasite management, as well as to investigate potential impediments to the adoption of IPM practices. This thesis forms part of the socioeconomic component of the IPM-s Project.1892 1315 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralFarmers, voluntary stewardship programs, and collaborative natural resource governance in rural Australia(2016); ; ; Monk, AndrewDespite large financial investments by governments and farmers, as well as significant inputs of time, effort and goodwill, the ecological, social and productive capacity of the Australian rural environment is under threat. The nature of natural resource problems, the limited capacity of rural communities to solve them, and current and future constraints on governments pose immense challenges of rural natural resource governance. Both traditional governance measures, centred on public laws, and purely private and self-regulatory forms seem unable to meet these challenges. This has spurred interest in collaborative modes, with the hope that they combine the best of both the public and private spheres. Collaborative experiments are already underway in rural Australia, including a model involving the co-opting of voluntary stewardship programs (VSPs) for farmers in natural resource co-regulation. But there is insufficient empirical examination of how such arrangements work in practice. The great hopes attached to the success of collaborative governance are mostly theoretical or based on applications that may not be relevant to rural natural resources in Australia. The lack of empirical validation of collaborative governance is a critical gap. Its practical efficacy may be underestimated or over-hyped. Empirical evaluation of natural resource issues is singularly difficult but, without some evaluation of the collaborative experiments, it will be hard for farmers, environmental organizations, governments, businesses along the agricultural supply chain, and citizens to make informed judgements about whether to embrace or reject collaborative arrangements. This study takes up this challenge by undertaking a preliminary investigation of some of the potential of VSPs for farmers in governance partnerships.4295 1015 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralFeasible Reforms for Thailand's Forest Governance System(2014) ;Phromlah, Wanida; ; ; This thesis aims to propose feasible reform directions for forest governance in Thailand that will provide greater social and environmental benefits from forestry and help overcome identified forest governance deficiencies. A review of the literature on forest governance suggests that 'good' governance plays a key role in ensuring sustainable natural forest management. Thailand has laws and institutions that, arguably, ought to ensure sustainable use of forest resources. Unfortunately, these forest governance actions to safeguard Thailand's forests have not achieved the expected result of reducing the destruction of forests, nor have they ensured social equity in the use of forest resources. This thesis draws on academic literature, legal sources and informal media - such as newspaper articles - and blends these with the 'voices' of directly involved stakeholders to diagnose the issues and arrive at a view about where reform is needed for the forest governance system in Thailand. The research is, therefore, underpinned by an engaged policy research methodology. Such a philosophy equally values the contribution of experts and of stakeholders in helping to define the issues and possible solutions to problems within a system and enables the development of a reform program that is more likely to deal with the full suit of relevant issues.4651 2516 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Thesis DoctoralPublication Floodplain Vegetation Landscapes: An Ecotone or a Dynamic Patch Mosaic?(2013) ;Shilpakar, Rajendra Lal; ; ; Floodplains are heterogeneous landscapes. The structural and functional heterogeneity of floodplain landscapes has commonly been described as a linear gradient with predictable changes from the main river channel to distal floodplain areas. In contrast to this, recent studies portray floodplains as dynamic patch mosaics. This thesis applied a landscape ecology approach along with remote sensing technology to characterize the structural and functional heterogeneity of the Yanga floodplain landscape; a semi-arid Australian floodplain. A conceptual framework was employed for analysing floodplain landscape structural and functional heterogeneity and describing their inter-linkages. In the framework, floodplain vegetation communities are the structural component of the landscape that forms the physical template upon which ecological processes occur. Flooding is considered to be the dominant driver of the Yanga floodplain ecosystem; it is the agent that alters the physical template - the floodplain vegetation template. The character of this altered template then influences the ecosystem response of the floodplain landscape. In this thesis, patterns of biomass production of eight various vegetation communities are the ecosystem response to inundation.2233 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralImproving the 'Rules of Engagement': Understanding how participatory processes are defined, experienced and implemented in Australian natural resource governance(2016); ; ; Alter, TheodoreCommunity action in natural resource governance can provide a pathway for improved decision-making, increased on-ground activity and acceptance of government and industry legitimacy in managing natural resources. Increasing the role of community in the protection, restoration and management of natural resources is a stated priority of ecologically sustainable development (ESD) principles. Despite a proliferation of legal requirements for public participation and non-legal guidelines that promote community access to environmental decision making at both the international and national scale, implementation is often unsatisfactory and difficult to evaluate.3898 907 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralA Longitudinal Resilience Comparison of Australian Regenerative and Conventional Beef Cattle Production Systems and the Establishment of a Set of Guiding Principles for Regenerative Agriculture in Australia(University of New England, 2024-07-10); ; ; ; Agricultural land covers 55% of the Australian landscape, with grazing the dominant agricultural land use. Climate change's current and predicted impacts are driving innovations within the livestock sector toward carbon-neutral and nature-positive outcomes. Regenerative agriculture in Australia has become a fast-developing movement that offers an alternative to industrial and conventional agriculture to mitigate the effects of climate change. The aims of this research are twofold; 1) to determine if Australian regenerative beef cattle production systems are more resilient than conventional systems in a changing climate and 2) to develop a set of guiding principles for regenerative agriculture in Australia.
The research has a multi-disciplinary approach utilising mixed methods, including a longitudinal case study of beef grazing systems in Northern New South Wales, Australia that incorporates the environmental, social, and economic indicators required for a resilience framework. Using these results, a set of principles for regenerative agriculture unique to Australian conditions was developed and tested to produce a guide for achieving resilience in a changing climate. This research is significant as it fills a gap in the theory and practice of Australian regenerative agriculture.
The overarching arching objective is to examine if regenerative beef cattle production systems are more resilient than conventional beef cattle production systems in a changing climate and whether comparing these production systems highlights the need for a set of guiding principles for regenerative agriculture in Australia. There were two themes within the research; the first addressed the resilience of regenerative and conventional farming systems, with the methodology including a literature review, case study, longitudinal survey, and thematic analysis. The second theme sought to establish a set of regenerative agricultural principles for Australia utilising a literature review and quantitative survey approach.
This thesis found the beliefs, orientations, and behaviours of Northern NSW beef farmers differ between regenerative and conventional cohorts, including differences in management action, forward planning, and strategy. It identified economic, environmental, and social indicators that align with the Stockholm Resilience Framework and affect a farmer's ability to remain resilient in a changing climate. Regenerative farmers rate higher against this resilience framework than conventional ’farmers in drought conditions and a changing climate, meaning regenerative farmers and their farms are more resilient in maintaining diversity and redundancy, managing connectivity, managing slow variables and feedbacks, encouraging learning and participation, and broadening participation. It concludes by finding that implementing regenerative practices will assist producers in being resilient in a changing climate.
The research proposes a set of principles for regenerative agriculture to guide future farming practices and management decision-making. These principles are:
1. Be ecologically literate, think holistically, and understand complex adaptive systems.
2. See your landscape as a community that you belong to and work with.
3. Remain curious; seek transformative experiences and continuous learning.
4. Acknowledge and consider diverse ways of working with landscapes.
5. Engage in ecological renewal and make place-based decisions through monitoring.
6. Engage with First Nations people.
7. Understand that human cultures are co-evolving with their environments.
These principles have the potential to act as a guide for future farming practices and management decision-making with the understanding that farming practices will continue to evolve, as will our knowledge and understanding of working with ecological systems. The principles can assist farmers in navigating climate change and the associated economic, environmental, and social disruption and uncertainty. In addition, this thesis supports farmers' ability to capitalise on the opportunities that are presenting themselves through regenerative agriculture practices, including ecosystem service markets, carbon sequestration, and enhancing landscape health and biodiversity.
788 273 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralOpportunities for, and Impediments to, Natural Resource Governance Innovation Illustrated by the Biofuels Weed Risk Case Study(2013) ;Le Gal, Elodie; ; This thesis is about innovation in natural resource governance. Established NRM models in either their command-and-control or deregulated market-based forms insufficiently achieve sustainable environmental outcomes and thus legal innovations are needed for protecting environmental values. Environmental law scholarship is mostly informed by a research paradigm which focuses upon individual instruments for environmental protection. By considering the broader governance system in which environmental and NRM governance models operate, this thesis argues that it is possible to: (i) design innovative environmental governance systems that can (in theory) better protect environmental values; (ii) mitigate the risks associated with innovative governance systems by better identifying them. However, the theoretical potential of policy innovation does not necessarily translate into feasibility. The second contribution of this research is to provide insights into the types of impediments that may inhibit practical implementation of innovative legal approaches. By using a pragmatic approach, this research aims to propose practical policy solutions to manage anthropogenic risks to environmental values and provide insights into theoretical tools to address NRM issues. This is illustrated with a case study focusing on the biofuel weed risk. While second-generation biofuel crops may produce bio-ethanol, help achieve a clean energy future, and help find the right balance between energy and food production, their use could also result in catastrophic biological infestations that may harm biodiversity values.3504 602 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralPawsitive Solutions: The symbiotic relationship between prisoners and dogs(2017) ;Humby, Lauren Michelle; ; With the prison population steadily increasing in Australia and over half of prisoners reoffending, it is evident that prison is ineffective for deterring and rehabilitating current and future offenders and reducing recidivism. As a result, there has been a gradual shift toward community corrections, placing an emphasis on interventions that address the criminogenic needs of prisoners. One such intervention is the implementation of prison dog programs (PDPs). PDPs involve a dog being paired with one or more specially selected inmates, who train, socialise and care for a dog for a specified period of time or until the animal is ready to be rehomed or move on to advanced training as an assistance or service dog. Although PDPs have been implemented in many correctional facilities in Australia, there is little evidence to support the existence of such programs. As such, this research sought to address this gap and add to the literature by conducting three studies. The first aimed to examine the nature and extent of PDPs operating in Australia through a national survey of eight corrections staff and 18 representatives from animal welfare, and training organisations involved in administering the program. The second study conducted semi-structured interviews with eight inmates, six corrections staff and one animal welfare representative involved in PDPs in Queensland, to identify the circumstances in which inmates are most likely to benefit from PDPs and how these programs can assist inmates in meeting their immediate and future needs. The third study aimed to explore the effect of PDPs on ten inmate participant's emotional intelligence; specifically, their ability to read emotions in others by comparing their ability, with current and previous dog owners, to provide judgements of emotion in photographs of dogs. The results of these studies support findings of other research and suggest that PDPs not only benefit inmates participating in PDPs, but also non-participant inmates, prison staff, prison culture, the dogs and society. The most reported benefits included positive changes to the prison environment, improved relationships with other inmates and staff and the opportunity to give back to society. The most commonly identified negative aspects were a lack of resources, personality clashes between inmates within the program and inmates' inability to socialise the dogs outside of the prison. Data from the studies as well as a review of the literature were used to develop a program logic model to improve the development, implementation, and evaluation of future PDPs.4812 1408 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Thesis DoctoralPublication Reflexive Learning in the Practice of Adaptive Freshwater Management(2016-10-22) ;McLoughlin, Craig; ; Learning-by-doing strategies allow for inherent uncertainty in the management of complex social-ecological systems. Adaptive management epitomises learning-by-doing, an iterative process based on incremental, experiential learning within adaptive management cycles. This learning is supported by strategic monitoring of, and feedback from the impacts and outcomes of decisions. Adaptive management of freshwater ecosystems facilitates a greater social context within freshwater management. This is achieved through an increased emphasis on flexible, open institutions and multi governance-level systems that allow for critical thinking and learning. Adaptive management of freshwater ecosystems is an important approach for practicing resilience because it addresses uncertainty in a complex world.
Lack of an effective natural resource management practice is frequently confounded by the requirement for complex social and technical (environmental) components to learning. Integrating societal learning based on increasing time-scales for social and technical change through the modes of single-, double-, and triple-loop learning, into adaptive natural resource management is intricate. This is because of many "enabling conditions" and facilitators associated with practicing this learning. Key "enabling conditions" for societal learning include stakeholder participation, learning-centred organizations, social learning capacities, and adaptive governance arrangements. In addition, reflexive learning (adaptive feedback systems) must be explicitly used and incorporated within adaptive management cycles in order to facilitate the three modes of societal learning. This thesis proposes that for efficient adaptive freshwater management single-, double-, and triple-loop learning must be exercised more deliberately within any adaptive freshwater management system, by the explicit facilitation of adaptive feedback systems.
The thesis employs an inductive approach to the research undertaken. It is comprised of two phases. The first phase involves the development of the frameworks, and aims to advance knowledge about the complex relationship between societal learning and the practice of adaptive natural resource management. The conceptual framework is hierarchical in nature and its design enhances understanding about how to integrate societal learning (the central learning construct) into adaptive natural resource management. Learning-centred organisations, which foster social learning capacities and achieve adaptive institutional arrangements within natural resource management have a place in adaptive natural resource management as critical enabling conditions for societal learning. However, development and use of a reflexive learning foundation of stakeholder networks and adaptive feedback systems is needed as a core mechanism for practicing single-, double-, and triple-loop learning. These feedbacks facilitate societal learning within adaptive natural resource management.
The development of the Strategic adaptive management Reflexive Learning Framework (SRLF) within this thesis uses a multi governance-level adaptive feedback system that works to enhance the facilitation of single-, double-, and triple-loop learning within adaptive natural resource management. The SRLF emphasizes the types, roles, and transfer of information within a reflexive learning context. The SRLF is a key enabler for implementing the adaptive management cycle, and thereby translating the theory of adaptive natural resource management into practice. It promotes the heuristics of adaptive management within a cohesive framework and its deployment guides adaptive natural resource management within and beyond typical single-loop learning, across all governance levels.
Under thesis phase two, application of the SRLF's adaptive feedback system to Ecological Reserve implementation in the Crocodile River Catchment of South Africa demonstrates the importance of the SRLF adaptive feedback system for societal learning and achieving ecosystem objectives. Adaptive feedbacks for lower grade single-loop learning are mandatory because frequent adjustment to Ecological Reserve operations is required due to uncertainty about implementing the required river flows. Upper grade single-loop learning is often neglected within the Crocodile River Catchment with too much attention focused on operations to implement the Ecological Reserve. However, these river flows are hypotheses about maintaining an agreed upon ecological condition in the rivers, and therefore must be assessed against end-point goal achievement, to adjust operations as required. The skill with incorporating double-loop learning is avoiding the trap of "learning for the sake of learning" because resources for this learning are scarce in the Crocodile River Catchment. However, reframing of interventions and end-point goals is required based on new knowledge becoming available and/or changing human values. Triple-loop learning is compulsory and deliberately imposed over longer time intervals because objectives require revision over time and stakeholder values also change. Triple-loop learning is required for completion and then regeneration of the adaptive management cycle.
Achieving societal learning within and across multiple governance levels within the Murray- Darling Basin is needed in order to practice an effective adaptive freshwater management. Societal learning is fostered via an explicit recognition of practitioner mandates across governance levels. In addition, by adopting a flexible objectives hierarchy and seeking stakeholder participation and finding adaptive management champions to steer the learning requirements. Achieving an effective balance between the modes of societal learning is key, while working toward implementing adaptive freshwater management in water resource plan areas of the Murray-Darling Basin is needed for stimulating learning in the upper governance levels.
Thesis chapters two to five are presented as manuscripts for journal publication. Each provide an original research contribution. Chapter Two advances our understanding about the complexity of learning within the practice of adaptive natural resource management (ANRM). Chapter Three demonstrates a unique way for deploying an adaptive feedback system within adaptive management cycles, for facilitating single-, double- and triple-loop learning within and across governance levels. Chapter Four sets an important precedent for implementing adaptive freshwater management in the real-world, using single-, double-, and triple-loop learning explicitly and deliberately within the adaptive management cycle. Lastly, Chapter Five advances our knowledge about how to implement adaptive freshwater management in the real-world, within and across governance levels. This adaptive freshwater management uses societal learning to embrace uncertainty under complex water reforms.
The thesis proposes that a complex adaptive feedback system must replace the typical linear interpretations of feedbacks within the adaptive management cycle, and therefore learning. In addition, a mind-set change is required for the translation of natural resource management theory into practice. The research (theory) mind-set, with its "idealism" frame-of-mind ("enhancing angle to learning") emphasises an enhanced version of societal learning within adaptive freshwater management, i.e. with full double-, and triple-loop learning occurring. However, in the real-world practice of adaptive freshwater management a "pragmatism" frame-of-mind ("requisite angle to learning") is needed. This mind-set focuses on getting single-loop and some initial form of double-loop learning going, within any given adaptive freshwater management system using current resources/structures available. Implementation of a complex nested and overlapping set of adaptive feedbacks is required to activate the more immediate responses, and adaptive assessment and reflection routines within the adaptive management cycle, and this bequeaths a critical foundation of "facilitating processes" for both learning angles. In addition, for assessing potential success or effectiveness of any given adaptive freshwater management system, taking a hierarchical, scaled perspective to implementation of the adaptive management cycle, across all governance levels, bestows a better gauging method for the practice of adaptive freshwater management. This is because societal learning is more achievable at the lower governance levels.
The SRLF and its principles developed in this thesis promote the practice of resilience. This is achieved via several emergent themes; thinking in multiple scales, paying attention to thresholds, celebrating/embracing change and uncertainty/surprise, fostering innovation, and remembering adaptive governance. Hence, the SRLF has implications for further research to advance knowledge about harnessing adaptive capacity within natural resource management (e.g. integrating with panarchy theory). In addition, research exploring application of the SRLF Environment theme with the other SRLF themes, i.e. Economic and Community/Social themes, is needed due to the integrated nature of freshwater legislation and management. Testing implementation of the SRLF principles at the upper governance levels of adaptive freshwater management is another area requiring further research, within a multiple governance-level practice of adaptive freshwater management.3609 324 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralRepresenting the Dingo: An Examination of Dingo-Human Encounters in Australian Cultural and Environmental Heritage(2017) ;Philip, Justine Mary ;Reid, Nick ;Garden, Don; The aim of my thesis is to document the cultural history and heritage of the ancient Australian canine, the dingo. An analysis of the complex symbiotic relationship between the dingo and human society for over 4,600 years reveals an animal uniquely positioned as both a human companion and top-order predator - fulfilling important ecosystem services across the Australian mainland, complementary to their role in traditional Aboriginal society. The thesis collates ethnographic, scientific and social representations of the dingo, and interrogates the legacy of 200 years of dingo control across the south-eastern third of the continent. I use a writing technique called a prosopography to explore areas of knowledge about dingoes, and the culture and heritage surrounding them. This involves recording human-animal encounters in the form of the stories of individual animals within a contextual history, revealing themes, patterns, inconsistencies and anomalies in dingo-human history. The listing of the species as endangered on the IUCN Red List (2004) and as a threatened species in the State of Victoria (2008) underscores the importance of critical analysis, revealing processes underlying the construction and dissemination of dingo knowledge that reinforce their cultural and physical marginalization. The study reveals a complex human-dingo history, and strives to present this information in a comprehensible format as a basis for discussion - allowing new insights into the unique history of the dingo's survival at the heart of traditional Aboriginal society and at the limits and borderlands of contemporary environmental management.4517 6455 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralSecrets to Cultural Identity; legal and institutional mechanisms to better support Torres Strait Islanders to maintain their cultural secrets(University of New England, 2019-03-11) ;McLaughlin, Christopher Neil; ; Torres Strait Islanders are a proud People with a strong physical and spiritual connection to their lands and waters in the Torres Strait, Australia. They present a unique and rich set of values, beliefs, geography, language and cultural practice, inextricably-linked to their cultural identity and vastly distinct from first-nation Australian Aboriginal peoples and the multi-cultural Australian mainland. Torres Strait Islanders practice a unique form of secrecy (Yagasin) applied towards the concealment and controlled revelation of sensitive Indigenous knowledge comprising the very building-blocks of their civilisation (their cultural secrets), itself cultural practice deriving from their traditional laws and customs acknowledged, connecting them spiritually to their lands and waters.
Most Australian statutory, common law and equitable legal mechanisms have proven ill-equipped to protect cultural secrets in their sui generis form and effectively remediate for spiritual impairment; the instruments fail to appreciate the primacy of the Indigenous spiritual world and communal interests distinct from Eurocentric proprietary interests in the physical world. When Indigenous people lose control of cultural secrets they are also likely to lose cultural identity, autonomy and power to control their own lives, rendering them helpless in the face of complex modern-day, ever-evolving political and economic relations.
This thesis explores legal and institutional mechanisms that may better support Torres Strait Islanders to protect their cultural secrets. The author argues that Native Title law is poised to emerge as the leading contender, best-equipped to provide tailored legal and institutional protection of Torres Strait Islander cultural secrets. Such a law would apply a regime which is neither an institution of the common law nor a form of common law tenure but nevertheless recognised by common law; it would provide a vital intersect with Torres Strait Islander traditional law and custom widely acknowledged.3183 1132 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Thesis DoctoralPublication A Tale of Success in Improving Coastal Floodplain Water Quality: A Case Study from Northern New South Wales, Australia(University of New England, 2019-10-02); ; Water security is a global challenge and faces significant threats from the impacts of human activities. Urban and rural demands for water are putting pressure on the quantity and quality of freshwater resources. Agriculture and land developments risk impacting the water quality of coastal floodplains and freshwater sources, particularly as much of the population in Australia resides on the coast. Attaining improved water security outcomes will require effective collaborative water governance strategies that can balance rural and urban uses, and importantly, balance those demands with maintaining healthy environments and ecosystems. A significant aspect for collaborative water governance to underpin water security outcomes will be the maintenance of appropriate levels of floodplain water quality and the quality of freshwater sources. Effective collaborative water governance outcomes in this regard will require good decisions to be made. Good decisions will require the utilisation and integration of different scientific and non-scientific knowledge types. However, collaborative water governance may exist in diverse arrangements including, top-down hierarchical, network, and as self-organised bottom-up initiatives. Each may face multiple and different challenges to achieve effective water security and quality outcomes due to diverse interconnected relationships between water and people within place-based contexts. Furthermore, there is limited understanding of the conditions and characteristics which may underpin the success of collaborative water governance in achieving effective outcomes. In response to this gap in understanding, this thesis conducted a case study into a community collaborative water governance initiative which successfully achieved improvements to water quality on a coastal floodplain in northern New South Wales, Australia. The research focus was to identify the factors, conditions and characteristics underpinning the success. It was found that successful outcomes of a community collaborative water governance initiative stem from effective collaboration, knowledge extension and utilisation, and recognition of the agency of place. Effective collaboration relies on a collaborative style of leadership which facilitates inclusive and open communication involving knowledge sharing and discussions. Knowledge extension and utilisation involved active engagement in research collaborations between landholders and researchers, and implementation of trial and error experimentation. From these processes scientific and local knowledges are shared and exchange leading to the co-production of placebased knowledge. Place-based knowledge provided a holistic understanding of the floodplain processes and a greater recognition of influence of place agency on management strategies and approaches. Lessons from this case study highlight the importance of place-based approaches to successful collaborative water governance in achieving effective water quality outcomes through a better understanding of place agency.
483 2 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Publication Open AccessThesis DoctoralUnderstanding Farmers’ Compliance with Agri-Food Safety Regulations in Kenya(University of New England, 2022-03-22); ; ; Compliance with agri-food safety regulations (e.g., pesticide use) is important for food security, public health management, and economic development in many developing countries. However, balancing the interests of consumers and food producers through a policy framework is complex and dynamic. Unfortunately, there is limited scholarly literature that explores farmers’ compliance with agri-food safety regulations in an African context, including Kenya. This thesis investigates farmers’ and agricultural industry insiders’ perceptions and attitudes about agri-food safety and agri-food safety regulations. It also examines farmers’ compliance with agri-food safety regulations in a major agricultural region in Kenya. These food safety regulations and laws are in response to the Kenyan Government’s aim to improve the quality and safety of agricultural products for local consumption and global trade by giving farmers increased responsibility for agri-food safety management. The study was informed by three theoretical frameworks: 1) the goal framing theory from the discipline of social psychology, 2) the rational choice theory, which is a cross-disciplinary framework, and 3) the routine activity theory, which is a criminological-based theory that focuses on understanding human deviant behaviour from a crime prevention perspective.
A sequential mixed-method design approach was adopted and involved collecting both quantitative and qualitative data and separately analysing each set of data. For the quantitative phase of the study, 160 farmers were surveyed using a semi-structured questionnaire during face-to-face interviews. Descriptive and hierarchical regression analyses were employed to analyse the quantitative data. The qualitative phase of the study involved six focus group discussions with 54 farmers and 29 key stakeholders in the agri-food chain, and the resulting data were analysed using the thematic method. The findings from the qualitative data were used to triangulate and enhance the findings from the quantitative study.
The survey results indicated that few farmers view agri-food safety as an agricultural challenge, especially among small-scale farmers. Both the survey results and focus group discussions also showed that farmers have low levels of awareness of some agri-food safety regulations. Furthermore, the two sets of data from the survey and focus group discussions revealed that farmers in the study area rarely comply with agri-food safety regulations. However, there were differences in perceptions between the farmers and the key agricultural insiders in relation to farmers’ compliance with agri-food safety regulations. The key informants tended to view farmers’ compliance levels as being higher than those indicated by the survey participants. Finally, both the farmer surveys and the key informant qualitative interviews revealed that farmers’ breaches of agrifood safety regulations are motivated by financial stress, pressure to conform to social norms, and the need to avoid feeling guilty for causing harm to another human being. Other factors found to influence farmers’ compliance with agri-food safety regulations were their lack of awareness of regulations and a lack of recognition of the legitimacy of government actions in the way regulations are designed and implemented.
The findings enhance understanding of farmers’ agri-food safety practices and their compliance with agri-food safety regulations in a developing country context. Moreover, the study extends the goal framing theory to the agricultural regulatory compliance literature. Importantly, it shows that the goal framing theory is useful for understanding farmers’ compliance with agri-food safety regulations in a developing country. In addition, the findings of this study should inform the development of effective, socially responsive, and acceptable agricultural and food policies and programs, especially for farmers in developing countries. The study forms a sound reference point for future studies on agricultural regulatory compliance.
640 207 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Thesis DoctoralPublication What is Water Really Worth? An Analysis of Innovative Approaches to Better Appreciate the Value of Water(University of New England, 2020-04-02) ;Charpleix, Liz Marjorie; Access to fresh, clean water is essential for the maintenance of healthy life for humans and nonhumans on Earth. As human populations have grown over time, access to clean water has become less secure across the globe. The research in this dissertation explores the possibility that deficiencies in water’s management have their roots in the way water is valued. It investigates innovative water valuation systems that may provide better solutions to the world’s water problems by identifying a greater range of water’s values.
The first category of innovative water valuation systems explored is hybrid economic approaches. Examples of these include the system of ecosystem services, which allocates value to the contributions of the natural world that generate goods or services that humans value, and Australia’s National Water Accounting system, which is based on financial accounting models. The next category examined is innovative legal approaches, including legal pluralism and legal personhood for nonhumans. This was investigated by conducting a case study of the Whanganui River in Aotearoa/New Zealand, which in 2017 was the first river in the world to be recognised as holding legal personhood. The third category scrutinised is innovative omnicentric approaches, which decentre humans in order to appreciate more fully the value of water. Common in Indigenous cultures, these include relational approaches that recognise nonhuman agency.
The methodology comprised a case study and an evaluation of different approaches to water valuation. Evaluation criteria included equity, as water is an essential good for humans and nonhumans; appropriateness, which assesses the need for a program; effectiveness, which assesses the extent of achievement of anticipated outcomes; and cultural and geographical transferability. Each approach was evaluated for its potential capacity to more fully appreciate the values of water by tallying its observed strengths and weaknesses.
The results indicate that each innovative valuation approach displays both strengths and weaknesses, suggesting a potential for creating hybrid models combining the strengths of different approaches. The strengths of innovative economic hybrids include visibilising water and encouraging transferability through globally cooperative economic systems. Their weaknesses relate to the incoherence between the profit motive upon which economic systems depend and the needs of actants, such as the environment, that are not well recognised in economic systems. Strengths observed in innovative legal approaches include the ability for plural legal systems, particularly those followed by Indigenous cultures, to meet nonhuman needs in addition to human ones. Weaknesses in effectiveness and equity exist due to the power differentials between dominant legal systems and Indigenous cultures. Strengths of the innovative omnicentric approach include its appropriateness for meeting the needs of the greatest range of human and nonhuman actants, its effectiveness in appreciating the agency of water and its potential for transferability across cultures that recognise nonhuman agency. Weaknesses in this approach include its lack of recognition in hegemonic economic systems, which may limit its transferability. As valuation methods evolve, improved solutions based on an appreciation of a wider range of values than the purely economic are more likely to be realised.
366 2