Broomhall, Anne Gene

Phillips, Wendy J

2024-01

<p>Upward counterfactual thinking involves imagining favourable situations that could have changed the outcome of a negative event. Although it has been reliably positively associated with depression, a causal relationship has not yet been investigated. This study addressed this gap in the literature by examining whether upward counterfactual thinking causally increases state depression. The online experimental study was conducted on 469 Philippine residents (<i>M</i>_age = 29.45; <i>SD</i> = 10.35; Range 18-72). As predicted, individuals who were induced to engage in an upward counterfactual thinking writing activity regarding a previous negative experience related to an unattained goal reported higher state depression relative to individuals who completed a neutral writing task. Consistent with the sequential negative cognitions-to-affect framework articulated by theories of depression, regret mediated the link between upward counterfactual thinking and depression. Contrary to expectation, induced upward counterfactual thinking increased state depression when perceived personal control over the negative experience was low or moderate but not when high. Future opportunity to change the negative experience was independently associated with decreased state depression but did not interact with upward counterfactual thinking to influence responses. Implications of these findings are discussed.</p>

Current Psychology, 43(1), p. 486-501

1936-4733

1046-1310

https://hdl.handle.net/1959.11/54492

Springer New York LLC

Upward counterfactual thinking and state depression: investigating a causal relationship

Journal Article

Publication