A Speculative Solution to the Instantiation and Structure Problems for Universals

Author(s)
Forrest, Peter
Publication Date
2018-04
Abstract
Typical structural universals are not just the mereological sum of their constituents. Hence, there is the Structure Problem of explaining this non-mereological structure. The Instantiation Problem is that the predicate "U is instantiated by x, y, etc., in that order" is ill-suited to be a primitive, unanalyzed predicate. The proposed solution to these problems is based on the observation that if universal U is said to supervene upon universals V, W, etc., then it is the instantiation of U that supervenes on the instantiation of V, W, etc. Assuming there are few subvenient universals, which is admittedly a speculation, their instantiation may be explained in ways that would be uneconomic if there were too many.
Citation
American Philosophical Quarterly, 55(2), p. 141-151
ISSN
2152-1123
0003-0481
Link
Publisher
University of Illinois Press
Title
A Speculative Solution to the Instantiation and Structure Problems for Universals
Type of document
Journal Article
Entity Type
Publication

Files:

NameSizeformatDescriptionLink