Alternative pollinator taxa are equally efficient but not as effective as the honeybee in a mass flowering crop

Title
Alternative pollinator taxa are equally efficient but not as effective as the honeybee in a mass flowering crop
Publication Date
2009
Author(s)
Rader, Romina
( author )
OrcID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9056-9118
Email: rrader@une.edu.au
UNE Id une-id:rrader
Howlett, Bradley G
Cunningham, Saul A
Westcott, David
Newstrom-Lloyd, Linda E
Walker, Melanie K
Teulon, David AJ
Edwards, Will
Type of document
Journal Article
Language
en
Entity Type
Publication
Publisher
Wiley-Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Place of publication
United Kingdom
DOI
10.1111/j.1365-2664.2009.01700.x
UNE publication id
une:19742
Abstract
1. The honeybee 'Apis mellifera' is currently in decline worldwide because of the combined impacts of Colony Collapse Disorder and the 'Varroa destructor' mite. In order to gain a balanced perspective of the importance of both wild and managed pollination services, it is essential to compare these services directly, a priori, within a cropping landscape. This process will determine the capacity of other flower visitors to act as honeybee replacements. 2. In a highly modified New Zealand agricultural landscape, we compared the pollination services provided by managed honeybees to unmanaged pollinator taxa (including flies) within a 'Brassica rapa var. chinensis' mass flowering crop. 3. We evaluate overall pollinator effectiveness by separating the pollination service into two components: efficiency (i.e. per visit pollen deposition) and visit rate (i.e. pollinator abundance per available flower and the number of flower visits per minute). 4. We observed 31 species attending flowers of 'B. rapa'. In addition to 'A. mellifera', seven insect species visited flowers frequently. These were three other bees ('Lasioglossum sordidum', 'Bombus terrestris' and 'Leioproctus' sp.) and four flies ('Dilophus nigrostigma', 'Melanostoma fasciatum', 'Melangyna novae'-zelandiae and 'Eristalis tenax'). 5. Two bee species, 'Bombus terrestris' and 'Leioproctus' sp. and one fly, 'Eristalis tenax' were as efficient as the honeybee and as effective (in terms of rate of flower visitation). A higher honeybee abundance, however, resulted in it being the more effective pollinator overall. 6. Synthesis and applications. Alternative land management practices that increase the population sizes of unmanaged pollinator taxa to levels resulting in visitation frequencies as high as 'A. mellifera', have the potential to replace services provided by the honeybee. This will require a thorough investigation of each taxon's intrinsic biology and a change in land management practices to ensure year round refuge, feeding, nesting and other resource requirements of pollinator taxa are met.
Link
Citation
Journal of Applied Ecology, 46(5), p. 1080-1087
ISSN
1365-2664
1472-0043
0021-8901
Start page
1080
End page
1087

Files:

NameSizeformatDescriptionLink