Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://hdl.handle.net/1959.11/12364
Title: Comments on Retallack, G. J. 2011: Problematic Megafossils in Cambrian Palaeosols of South Australia
Contributor(s): Jago, James B (author); Gehling, James G (author); Paterson, John R  (author)orcid ; Brock, Glenn A (author)
Publication Date: 2012
DOI: 10.1111/j.1475-4983.2012.01173.x
Handle Link: https://hdl.handle.net/1959.11/12364
Abstract: The purpose of this comment is to question the organic nature of the material described by Retallack (2011) as 'problematic megafossils' from the Moodlatana and Balcoracana Formations, Lake Frome Group of the Flinders Ranges, South Australia. By way of introduction, we note that there is a considerable history of structures described from sedimentary rocks as fossils that do not stand up to scrutiny (Hofmann 1971, 1992, 2005). The literature is replete with what Hofmann (1992) regarded as dubiofossils. The onus should always be on the author to demonstrate biological origins. Retallack (2011, p.1223) in discussing the need to name problematic fossils states that 'Vendobionta were informally noted by Mawson (1938, p. 259) as 'fossil impressions resembling brachiopod or bivalve form', but formal description of five species by Sprigg (1947) was needed before their global distribution and importance as Ediacaran fossils could be appreciated (Fedonkin et al. 2007).' This is misleading because Mawson's complete sentence is 'Fossil impressions resembling brachiopod or bivalve form, but probably merely impressions of clay galls'. Mawson was in fact describing a section through what would now be termed the Ediacaran Rawnsley Quartzite, from about 1.6 km north of Parachilna Creek and about 50 km to the south east of where Sprigg (1947) initially found the Ediacara biota near Ediacara in the Rawnsley Quartzite.
Publication Type: Journal Article
Source of Publication: Palaeontology, 55(4), p. 913-917
Publisher: Wiley-Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Place of Publication: United Kingdom
ISSN: 1475-4983
0031-0239
Fields of Research (FoR) 2008: 040308 Palaeontology (incl Palynology)
Fields of Research (FoR) 2020: 370506 Palaeontology (incl. palynology)
Socio-Economic Objective (SEO) 2008: 970106 Expanding Knowledge in the Biological Sciences
970104 Expanding Knowledge in the Earth Sciences
Socio-Economic Objective (SEO) 2020: 280102 Expanding knowledge in the biological sciences
280107 Expanding knowledge in the earth sciences
HERDC Category Description: C4 Letter of Note
Appears in Collections:Journal Article

Files in This Item:
2 files
File Description SizeFormat 
Show full item record

SCOPUSTM   
Citations

8
checked on Mar 23, 2024

Page view(s)

1,136
checked on Feb 11, 2024
Google Media

Google ScholarTM

Check

Altmetric


Items in Research UNE are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.