Natural Laws, Vacant Niches and Superorganisms. A Response to Woodley

Title
Natural Laws, Vacant Niches and Superorganisms. A Response to Woodley
Publication Date
2008
Author(s)
Rohde, Klaus
Type of document
Journal Article
Language
en
Entity Type
Publication
Publisher
Tilgher-Genova
Place of publication
Italy
UNE publication id
une:5081
Abstract
Woodley ([2007], [2008]) claims that evolution proceeds in a process of lineage degeneration, which, unlike adaptation, is seen as a generally unidirectional and "law-like" tendency. The main evidence given is orthogenesis demonstrated for various lineages. He further claims that ecosystems become "routinely saturated", i.e., ecosystems are not far out of equilibrium. Evidence given is the negative correlation between invasion success and ecosystem diversity, as well as Hubbell’s neutral theory of biogeography and biodiversity, which assumes saturation of communities and has made some correct predictions. Woodley wants to restrict the term vacant niche to cases where regions of unoccupied niche space exist that are "parameterised by but not occupied by surrounding niches". Although he admits that resource space may be "globally unsaturated", it is "locally saturated in places". He insists that convergence is beneficial to ecosystems, since "ecosystems exhibit superorganismal properties and can be considered as complex adaptive systems in their own right." Evidence he mentions is group selection in microbial ecosystems.
Link
Citation
Rivista di Biologia, 101(3), p. 340-346
ISSN
1825-6538
0035-6050
Start page
340
End page
346

Files:

NameSizeformatDescriptionLink